Is 16T Pulley the cause of VFA? Microscope photos - PRUSA VS POWGE VS TRIANGLE
 
Notifiche
Cancella tutti

Is 16T Pulley the cause of VFA? Microscope photos - PRUSA VS POWGE VS TRIANGLE  

  RSS
Goyetus
(@goyetus)
Trusted Member
Is 16T Pulley the cause of VFA? Microscope photos - PRUSA VS POWGE VS TRIANGLE

Seeing that one of the possible causes or reasons for the VGA of the parts printed in CoreOne, and with the similarity that have these VFA correlating with the Pitch of the belt or the pulleys ..... I have taken some microscope pictures of 3 pulleys I had at home.

- Powge
- TriangleLabs
- Prusa

In my opinion, the Prusa ones seem to be the best machined, or at least, where a particular tooth looks cleaner than on other brands.

Unfortunately, the pictures are not taken with a good quality microscope. But I think they can be useful to get a general idea.

IMPORTANT:  7mb png file is attached to this thread.  The photos are low resolution,  use attached PNG if you want ZOOM IN !!!!!

 

 

Questa discussione è stata modificata 2 months fa 2 tempo da Goyetus
Postato : 25/06/2025 4:27 pm
4 persone hanno apprezzato
Goyetus
(@goyetus)
Trusted Member
Topic starter answered:
RE:

Last photo is incorrect,  This one is the correct. Cant edit the OP.

Questo post è stato modificato 2 months fa da Goyetus
Postato : 25/06/2025 4:41 pm
1 persone hanno apprezzato
SgtCaffran
(@sgtcaffran)
Estimable Member
RE: Is 16T Pulley the cause of VFA? Microscope photos - PRUSA VS POWGE VS TRIANGLE

Thanks for contributing. You do not have some pulleys from Mellow 3D in order, by any chance?

Postato : 25/06/2025 5:05 pm
Goyetus
(@goyetus)
Trusted Member
Topic starter answered:
RE:

No, sorry.  Mellow is the only one I dont have.    I purchased POWGE,  as they seems to be better quality than Mellow. 
Mellow should be equal or worst to TriangleLabs.....

I am surprised at people who have better VFA with Mellow pulleys.

EDIT: 
I will love to see this test  with a good microscope. 

Questo post è stato modificato 2 months fa da Goyetus
Postato : 25/06/2025 5:07 pm
1 persone hanno apprezzato
Condividi: