PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
Not sure if I've stumbled onto a slicer bug or what. Thought I'd ask.
I'm using PrusaSlicer-2.1.0+-201909160907 to work with models from the Pela Blocks project. I've calibrated and etc, and generated a smaller socket panel for testing and etc by editing PELA-socket-panel.scad, exporting the STL file from OpenSCAD and importing it into PrusaSlicer.
When I print it, one of the holes is occluded.
Here's what it looks like after slicing:
Here's what it looks like when I import it (which matches what I see in OpenSCAD):
I've attached the STL file.
g.
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
Hmm, would allow me to attach the stl file. Perhaps if I hide it in a tar file.....
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
Ok, can't seem to attach the STL file. Sigh.... Open to suggestions.
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
Here's a link to the file, temporarily hosted: https://shrimp.alerce.com/tmp/PELA-socket-panel.stl
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
Hi George, if you ZIP the STL, you can then attach the zip file
regards Joan
I try to make safe suggestions,You should understand the context and ensure you are happy that they are safe before attempting to apply my suggestions, what you do, is YOUR responsibility. Location Halifax UK
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
"One or more of your objects are invalidly defined" according to 3D Builder.
Open your STL file with 3D Builder (a free Microsoft tool).
Import the object. 3D Builder will find that error. Let it fix it.
Save your file. It will replace your original.
Now when you slice, it will be perfect.
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
Let's try attaching a zip file.
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
"One or more of your objects are invalidly defined" according to 3D Builder.
Open your STL file with 3D Builder (a free Microsoft tool).
Import the object. 3D Builder will find that error. Let it fix it.
Save your file. It will replace your original.
Now when you slice, it will be perfect.
Don't have anything that'll run 3d-builder. If the stl file is "bad", then I assume this is an OpenSCAD bug?
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
@robert-rmm200 -- Can you diff the before and after versions of the STL file and see what's been changed?
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
@george-h9
Above my pay grade. But I can upload my "fixed" stl.
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
Why on earth do people post files in foreign-to-most-OS files. ZIP is the format. bin, jar, rar, gx, .ztar, 7zip, and similar formats are NOT common for 90% of the computer users in the world. May as well not post them.
And, if you take to time to post something, at lease verify the file you are posting isn't empty. While I enjoy the occasional foo-bar, a bar folder is not exactly useful.
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
I've opened an issue about this on the OpenSCAD site: https://github.com/openscad/openscad/issues/3114
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
Thanks for the upload. For some reason, I thought that these were text file that were diffable, but they don't appear to be. Sorry for the noise.
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
Why on earth do people post files in foreign-to-most-OS files. ZIP is the format. bin, jar, rar, gx, .ztar, 7zip, and similar formats are NOT common for 90% of the computer users in the world. May as well not post them.
And, if you take to time to post something, at lease verify the file you are posting isn't empty. While I enjoy the occasional foo-bar, a bar folder is not exactly useful.
Tim, what are you going on about?
Nothing posted in this topic, by anyone, was empty...
Just curious - what is a "bar folder"?
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
I'm uploading multi-part zoo archives from now on, baby!
and miscellaneous other tech projects
He is intelligent, but not experienced. His pattern indicates two dimensional thinking. -- Spock in Star Trek: The Wrath of Khan
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
FWIW, the folks over in OpenSCAD world don't seem to think that there's any problem with the STL file that's being exported. Details here: https://github.com/openscad/openscad/issues/3114
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
Tim - I found your Bar folder, posted by the OP. Makes more sense now.
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
I remeshed that one octagon surface and the problem went away; but Meshmixer didn't flag anything.
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
Tim, apologies. I'm a long-time unix user, my goto format, for a very long time, has been compressed tar files. zip files are my odd men out.
I did, indeed, screw up when I created the file I initially posted in my GitHub issue. Like I said, not a regular zip-per. I'm human, I guess.... I dropped the file into a throw-away sub-directory because it drives me nuts when unpacking archive files mixes up their contents with the current dir's bits.
RE: PrusaSlicer bug slicing Pela Block socket panel?
I remeshed that one octagon surface and the problem went away; but Meshmixer didn't flag anything.
Thanks for poking at it.
Does that point to a bug in the OpenSCAD output, or ???