Nozzle type
Hello,
I have my Prusa now a few months and was thinking about changing the nozzle diameter.
My question now is it worth getting a plated copper nozzle over the normal brass? I read that steel is not as heatconductive. So if I want a larger diameter (0.8) the flowrate is higher and I would think a plated copper would be better.
Does anyone have experience and comparison between plated copper and brass nozzle?
Thanks
Best regards
"Man who says it cannot be done should not interrupt man doing it" -Confucius
RE: Nozzle type
Tech, filament may stick less to plated copper compared to brass - less sticking better. I use a 0.6 for my larger nozzle - PrusaSlicer has profiles for the 0.6 nozzle and I'm getting good results with that stock profile. I think anything that keeps the heat stable is a good thing so I switched to plated copper nozzles (and silicone socks) quite a while ago - I did not do comparison prints but effect on my bank balance was noticeable.
Cheers
Digbat
TANSTAAFL
RE: Nozzle type
Plated nozzles are great for printing PETG and other sticky materials that tend to want to glom onto the hottest nearby object. A plated nozzle along with a silicone sock have transformed my maintenance routine, and I'm spending a lot less time cleaning the nozzle and heater block these days.
Be aware that there are (at least) 2 varieties of coated nozzles:
- P3-D and E3D both make coated copper nozzles. E3D offers nickel-plated copper, while P3-D uses a specialized coating on aluminum in their Apollo series. Both claim superior thermal characteristics to brass (P3-D info here) and while harder than bare brass, neither are "hardened" nozzles suitable for printing abrasives like carbon-fibre or glow-in-the-dark filament.
- P3-D and E3D both make hardened coated nozzles. P3-D has their Hercules series and E3D has Nozzle-X. Both of these are coated, but both are also hardened steel (see P3-D info above) with lower thermal characteristics than brass. I've been doing some throughput testing (chaotic results here) and Nozzle-X does indicate that it can maintain a flow almost identical to plain brass, so it's a great all-around nozzle. I have not yet tested the P3-D Hercules in head-to-head conditions.
and miscellaneous other tech projects
He is intelligent, but not experienced. His pattern indicates two dimensional thinking. -- Spock in Star Trek: The Wrath of Khan
RE: Nozzle type
Thanks for the replies.
So how I understand it for PLA it doesn't really make that much of a difference.
What do you mean with "silicone sock"?
"Man who says it cannot be done should not interrupt man doing it" -Confucius
RE: Nozzle type
So how I understand it for PLA it doesn't really make that much of a difference.
The combination of a coated nozzle and sock will help with PLA. PETG is more sticky and prone to getting in all the wrong places, but even PLA can benefit.
I had a print go bad and nearly had a "Blob of Doom" experience:
Fortunately, the combination of coated nozzle and silicone sock kept it from getting up into the hotend:
What do you mean with "silicone sock"?
The sock is the blue cover that fits over the heater block. You can see it in the picture above around the nozzle. Search for "E3D silicone sock" to find them.
and miscellaneous other tech projects
He is intelligent, but not experienced. His pattern indicates two dimensional thinking. -- Spock in Star Trek: The Wrath of Khan
RE: Nozzle type
Thanks for the info. I never heard of such a sock but it makes sense. My hotend looks quite a mess. So i guess my next order is on its way 🙂
"Man who says it cannot be done should not interrupt man doing it" -Confucius
RE: Nozzle type
I mostly print in PETG and have switched to nickel coated nozzles from MicroSwiss - they are great to clean and I am not switching back...
MicroSwiss claims that the coating on their nozzles (TwinClad XT) is hard, very low friction and wear resistant - I have never tried abrasive filament so no experience here. Price for a nozzle is around $15.
Have a look at my models on Printables.com 😉
RE: Nozzle type
How do you find the top surface looks with the micro swiss?, I've so far stuck with E3d (Nickel plated copper) as I believe the flatter tip end will help 'iron' the top of the round extrusions and pump more heat into the extruded material and help push the extrusion into the previous layer.
What are maximum extrusion widths like with this pointy type of nozzle?.
Thanks.
Normal people believe that if it ainât broke, donât fix it. Engineers believe that if it ainât broke, it doesnât have enough features yet.
RE: Nozzle type
The surface from MicroSwiss is more flat than the standard nozzle, but not a replacement for "ironing" function found in slicers like Cura. After more than a year of usage I see no wear at the tip.
My nozzles is all 0.4 mm size and haven't experimented with wider extrusion tracks.
Have a look at my models on Printables.com 😉
RE: Nozzle type
Thanks for the replies.
So how I understand it for PLA it doesn't really make that much of a difference.
What do you mean with "silicone sock"?
RE: Nozzle type
Titanium carbide seems to be the "perfect nozzle material", but TiC nozzles are quite expensive. I've found my nickel plated copper nozzles (from MatterHackers) to be much easier to keep clean than the original brass one while working at least as well, and they're inexpensive. The tradeoff is that they're not abrasion-resistant, but I don't even own any abrasive filaments.
RE: Nozzle type
Thanks for the replies. I will try the "simple" nickel plated copper. They are already ordered 🙂
"Man who says it cannot be done should not interrupt man doing it" -Confucius
RE: Nozzle type
If you haven't already, then I would really recommend the silicone nozzle socks: https://e3d-online.com/v6-silicone-socks-pack-of-3
This keeps your heater block clean, keeps your temperature stable (Run a PID hotend tune with the sock on first) and lasts a long time.
There are also a number of forum members who have got away with the blob of death thanks to a silicone sock as it stopped the filament melting all over their hot end. I've been using the same one for about a year now but also don't run the printer 24/7 and have even printed a few poly-carbonate parts with the hot end at 300 Deg C, but this temperature will eventually destroy the silicone, yet 250 Deg and below and it is fine.
Maybe bobstro or someone else whom uses their printer a lot more than me can comment on life expectancy, but even so, treat it as a consumable.
Normal people believe that if it ainât broke, donât fix it. Engineers believe that if it ainât broke, it doesnât have enough features yet.
RE: Nozzle type
Yes, I ordered some socks with 🙂
"Man who says it cannot be done should not interrupt man doing it" -Confucius