Avisos
Vaciar todo

blob detection  

  RSS
Markov
(@markov)
Active Member
blob detection

Why can't the MK4S detect a blob? I presume that with the added mass that the current for the motor drivers would increase. Or the tap sensor would show a constant detection. Or the temp sensor would not register proper cooling from the fans.

 

Why can't the MK4S sense blobs?Blobs happen to all

Respondido : 23/03/2026 5:32 pm
Markov
(@markov)
Active Member
Topic starter answered:
RE: blob detection

What? .... Why is there TWO posts and WHY is it in the OpenPrintTag forum? This is NOT where I posted it!

Respondido : 24/03/2026 3:46 am
mnentwig
(@mnentwig)
Honorable Member
RE:

I see it as a fairly difficult problem without sensors e.g. camera. AI might do a "reasonably good job" at it in theory if the printer may borrow your graphics card.
Still, given the low probability of a blob-of-doom and high cost of false detection (failed print) it might do more harm than good in everyday work. I don't want to lose a print over every new non-critical irregularity I run into. That said, it may be possible to find a few meaningful thresholds, the real problem being you'd need to hire a few new guys in support for the "exceptions".

I see Prusa's overall direction selling "printers that are not trying to be smarter than the users". Other vendors see this as an opportunity - of course the feature exists on competing products with said AI/camera on a more modern hardware platform, higher integration level (using state-of-the-art but short-lived chips) etc. Whether any of those boxes will still be in operation five to ten years down the road, time will tell. 

A more realistic route, make sure spaghetti-monster-meets-blob-of-doom incidents are prevented by other means - bed adhesion, control warping, understand your printer.

Esta publicación ha sido modificada el hace 2 hours por mnentwig
Respondido : 24/03/2026 6:42 am
Compartir: